
Many early-career scientists approach the question and answer session with dread, believing it to be an arcane grilling ritual or a chance to trip speakers up on their own words.
In reality, most questioners are genuinely interested in understanding what they just heard or providing additional information. It’s really the most valuable part of the presentation for you—getting feedback on your work and new ideas from some brilliant minds. As always, practicing fielding questions is the most efficient way to get better. You want to be comfortable enough so that 10 minutes later, when you sit down, you can remember what you were asked and how you answered.
Things to Do
Always repeat the question. It serves several important purposes —to make sure everyone in the room heard the question, to make sure you understood what the speaker was actually asking, to give yourself some time to think about your answer, and to stimulate other questions.
Have your own ‘question’ on hand. Nothing is worse than getting no questions, so have a point in reserve to jump start the discussion. Say something like, “Here’s a point I didn’t cover…” or “You may be wondering why we did this…”
It’s okay to admit when you don’t know the answer. Get comfortable saying, “We hadn’t thought of that, but it is a good point.” or “It is not known yet, whether…” And avoid saying, “I don’t know.” when you really mean, “The field does not know.”
Practice escape phrases. Simple things, such as “Let’s talk afterwards,” can get you unstuck if you freeze or draw a blank on a particular question.
“When I know I’m going to be nervous, I practice the touchstone phrases in every slide. I might practice them while I’m exercising, just to get those phrases. What do I really need to communicate on that slide?”
— Dr. Leslie Kean, Emory University
Things Not to Do
Don’t answer a question you don’t understand. Ask the speaker to come up afterward. And don’t launch into a different answer altogether just because you can—that is a waste of the audience’s time.
Don’t be caught off-guard by a question that you have already answered in your talk. At any given time, only 70-80 percent of your audience is paying attention. If someone asks a question that you covered, simply state it again. Don’t assume he or she is asking something deeper—if so, he or she will clarify.
Never get defensive. It changes the tone of the whole situation and will leave your audience with a negative impression of you. Remember, if someone seems to attack your work, it’s most likely not about you, personally, so don’t take it that way. Especially during a job talk, consciously tell yourself to relax and enjoy the give-and-take.
Don’t hide from a question. If there’s a question you fear, incorporate that point into the talk and open the door for it. Otherwise, you risk being in a frame of mind where every question will seem like it’s picking at that one point.
Always answer questions respectfully. You never know who’s doing the asking and a rude or flippant response to a senior or well-respected scientist will do more damage to you. Likewise, don’t belittle a competitor, an alternative interpretation of an emerging story, or (remarkably, people do this) your own past or current advisors.
Tricky questions
Oddball questions: If you get a question that seems unrelated to your work or extremely naive, remember, many of those in your audience will be outsiders to your field of study. Take a moment to think about how you might best explain the field history in relation to your work or draw parallels to the questioner’s field if you know it. Never make someone feel bad for asking a question, be gracious.
Getting questions in the middle of a talk: If someone’s hand goes up during your talk, you can take the question if you are at a comfortable point. But don’t let it derail you. If you would rather wait until the end, smile or nod at the person to let them know you will come back to them. It’s a good idea to ask your host ahead of time if questions are normally fielded or held until the end.
Competitor’s questions: You may often get the same question from a competing group at conferences. It may be wise to plan ahead for how best to address a weakness in your data or approach. “Have a standard Dr. X rebuttal plan that asserts confidence in your research without sullying her reputation,” advises Dr. Leslie Kean, of Emory.